Dr. Peter C. Kang’s surgical journal · Seoul

Rib cartilage in revision rhinoplasty: what is it supporting?

Editorial guide drawing on Dr. Peter C. Kang’s published case records and the sources identified below. Updated . How this journal uses evidence.

The short answer

In the cases below, rib cartilage was used to rebuild weakened or missing nasal support. The useful question is not simply whether rib cartilage was used, but where it was placed and which structural problem it addressed. A graft source, a surgical approach and a desired appearance are three different parts of the treatment plan.

Start with the structure, then discuss the material

The journal includes a case in which almost no septum remained after two operations, another involving revision after ear-cartilage rhinoplasty, and a third involving removal of an L-shaped silicone implant. Autologous rib cartilage appears in all three records, but the starting problem and accompanying procedures were different.

When reading a proposed operation, ask which part of the nose needs support, what tissue remains there and what the graft is intended to do. The presence of rib cartilage on a list of procedures is not a complete explanation of the reconstruction.

Keep these terms separate

Terms used in surgical records
TermMeaning in the plan
Autologous cartilageCartilage taken from the patient's own body. The donor location should be specified.
Donor rib cartilageCartilage from a donor source; it is not the same as harvesting the patient's own rib cartilage.
Septal reconstructionThe structure being rebuilt. The record should also identify the material used.
Implant removal or replacementA separate step involving an existing artificial implant. A cartilage graft and an implant can have different roles in the same case.

Ask for the material and its purpose to be named separately for the tip, septum and bridge. This is particularly useful if several materials were used in earlier operations.

Compare records with the same starting problem

A meaningful comparison begins with the previous operations and remaining anatomy. In case 224332794085, the record describes septal cartilage deficit together with asymmetry and obstruction. In case 224337820863, the patient sought a slimmer line after earlier rhinoplasty, and the operation included several additional procedures.

Those records cannot establish that rib cartilage is required for every revision, or that the result of one operation predicts another. They show how a material can be used as one component of a wider plan.

Questions about donor sites and long-term change

The case records discuss chest donor-site scarring and pain, rare pleural injury, and the possibility of cartilage warping or resorption. Ask which of those considerations apply to the proposed graft source and how changes would be assessed during follow-up.

  • Which structure would each graft support?
  • Why is this source proposed in my case?
  • What are the alternatives and their limitations?
  • What donor-site care would be needed if my own rib cartilage is used?
  • Which follow-up observations would show whether support and appearance remain stable?

Related surgical records

Original record ·

Rib Cartilage Reconstruction After Two Nose Surgeries

After two previous nasal surgeries, this patient experienced nearly total loss of the septum, bilateral nasal bone asymmetry, and persistent breathing discomfort. Using a closed approach, autologous rib cartilage was utilized to rigidly reconstruct the deficient septum. In addition, nasolabial angle adjustment, asymmetric osteotomy correction, and lowering of the radix were performed together.

Read the clinical record →

Original record ·

Key considerations when revising ear cartilage rhinoplasty with autologous rib cartilage

This is a case where the patient desired a slimmer, softer nasal line after a first surgery using ear cartilage and septal cartilage. Autologous rib cartilage was used to reinforce support for the nasal tip and adjust the nasolabial angle, and the silicone implant was replaced to lower the radix. Nasal sill reduction and full-face autologous fat grafting were performed concurrently to balance the facial contour.

Read the clinical record →

Original record ·

Silicone Implant Removal and Nasal Tip Reconstruction

This is a case where the nasal tip skin thinned and became upturned after the insertion of an L-shaped silicone implant about 10 years ago. The existing L-shaped implant causing pressure on the skin was completely removed. Autologous rib cartilage was harvested to reconstruct a stable nasal tip, dermal tissue was reinforced over the thinned skin, and the nasolabial angle was corrected.

Read the clinical record →

These are individual surgical records. Check the photograph timing and follow-up described in each case; an immediate postoperative view is not a long-term outcome.

Common questions

Is rib cartilage necessary for every revision rhinoplasty?

These records do not support that conclusion. Material selection depends on the reconstruction being considered and the tissue available in the individual case.

Does rib cartilage mean the operation is implant-free?

Not necessarily. Some published operations used rib cartilage and an implant for different purposes. Ask for each material and its location to be identified.

Is donor rib cartilage the same as my own rib cartilage?

No. Autologous rib cartilage comes from the patient; donor rib cartilage comes from a donor source. Ask which is proposed and what its specific risks and follow-up requirements are.

Continue reading

Sources and further reading

External sources provide general context. The linked surgical records document individual cases; they do not establish a clinic-wide success rate or an endorsement by the organizations cited.

Enlarged photo WhatsAppChat with NOSELAB